Premier League clubs have approved a significant change to the organisation’s legal rules, agreeing to cover the legal expenses of five senior board members if Manchester City’s sponsors take them to court.
The decision was reached during a meeting in London on Thursday. It was the first gathering of Premier League clubs since an independent commission found Manchester City guilty of multiple breaches of the competition’s financial regulations in September.
City have challenged the findings and continue to insist that they are innocent. The club’s appeal is ongoing, and no final punishment has been announced.
However, the situation has become more complicated following indications from two of Manchester City’s sponsors, Etihad Airways and Etisalat, that they may pursue legal action against the Premier League.
Premier League Extends Legal Protection for Five Directors
Under the league’s previous articles of association, directors were entitled to financial protection when they successfully defended legal claims brought against them by third parties. That protection did not extend to cases they lost.
The newly approved amendment changes those arrangements. It will provide legal indemnity to Premier League chief executive Richard Masters, chair Alison Brittain and three additional non-executive directors, meaning their legal costs will be covered even if they fail to win a case.
Manchester City and Nottingham Forest were the only clubs to vote against the proposal. The other 18 Premier League teams supported it, allowing the amendment to pass.
The decision carries potentially major financial consequences for all member clubs. Under the league’s collective responsibility arrangements, every club could be required to contribute towards the legal expenses. The overall bill could potentially reach hundreds of millions of pounds.
This creates an unusual situation in which Manchester City could indirectly face financial costs if legal proceedings brought by its own commercial partners result in expenses for the Premier League.
BBC Sport reported that City chief financial officer Ingo Bank raised the issue during Thursday’s meeting. He asked Brittain whether the proposed rule change was directly connected to the legal threats made by Etihad and Etisalat. Brittain reportedly declined to comment.
Why Nottingham Forest Opposed the Proposal
Nottingham Forest also voted against the amendment, although its reasons are understood to have been related to the decision-making process rather than support for Manchester City.
The club reportedly believed that Premier League members had not been given enough information or sufficient time to assess the proposed changes. Forest was particularly concerned about the scale of the financial obligations that could arise from the new arrangements.
Its position was that an amendment with potentially such significant consequences deserved more detailed examination before clubs were asked to approve it.
Manchester City’s Financial Case Remains Under Appeal
The background to the dispute dates back to the Premier League’s investigation into Manchester City’s financial dealings.
In September, an independent commission concluded that City had artificially increased their reported revenue by more than £830 million over a nine-year period. The commission also found that the club had used sponsorship agreements described as “sham” contracts to disguise funding from its owners, the Abu Dhabi United Group.
Premier League chief executive Richard Masters previously accused Manchester City of systematically breaching the competition’s financial regulations over almost a decade.
City have consistently rejected the allegations and appealed against the commission’s conclusions. The case remains unresolved, with the eventual outcome and any possible sanctions still to be determined.
Etihad and Etisalat Consider Legal Action
The possibility of court proceedings emerged publicly in October, when Etihad Airways confirmed that it was considering legal action against the Premier League.
The UAE-based airline strongly disputed the commission’s conclusions and rejected any suggestion that it had been involved in improper commercial arrangements.
Etisalat subsequently indicated that it could take a similar step. Earlier this month, the telecommunications company described the Premier League’s verdict as “entirely false and defamatory”.
The potential challenges from both sponsors have placed additional pressure on the league as it prepares for the next stage of the Manchester City case.
With the new legal protection rules now approved, the dispute could have consequences extending beyond City and the Premier League’s leadership. All 20 clubs may ultimately face financial exposure as the legal situation develops.
For more coverage of the latest Premier League developments, Manchester City news and major football stories, visit Football Score Today.
